Balancing Emotion with Reason in Your Finances

by Christina on March 1, 2012

The following post is from Christina of Northern Cheapskate:

a boy and his dog

photo credit: Christina Brown

A few weeks ago, our little 10-year old terrier was accidentally poked in the eye.  At first, she seemed fine. And then I noticed her eye was gooey, and she wasn’t opening it all the way.  We’ve made several trips to the vet for check-ups and eye drops, and because her eye isn’t healing, she’s scheduled to have surgery this week.  We’ve already put a couple hundred dollars into this injury, and now we’ll add another several hundred onto our tab as well as some regular maintenance (she’s due for some shots).

Pets are expensive.  I knew that when we got her 10 years ago.  But I wasn’t as prepared for the emotional tug-of-war between our beloved family fur ball and our wallet.

I could never let an innocent animal suffer, especially one that is our responsibility.  We’ll come up with the money for the expenses, and we’ll survive.

But it really got me thinking about how our emotions are connected to our finances.  We’re rushed into making decisions by well-meaning friends.  We overspend on gifts for our loved ones.  We’re charmed by children into spending money on little treats.  We shop when we’re bored or lonely, or sad, or to celebrate.

When you allow your emotions to rule your wallet, you’re on a slippery slope.  It becomes all too easy to justify wants as needs.

I’m slowly learning that finding a balance between emotion and reason is critical to being a good steward of both your money and your heart.

I’m learning that there are a few parts of the decision-making process that can help you find balance:

Ask as many questions as you can.

Do your homework.  You can’t make a good decision without having all of the information.  My dog is part of the family not helping her is not an option.  But I didn’t let my love for our pet override my financial sense. I asked plenty of questions about treatment options and how to make her comfortable.  We tried lower cost, less invasive treatments first.  And we investigated worst case scenarios. We got estimates for the various treatments, and I researched the options. I wanted our family to be prepared both emotionally and financially for whatever her treatment brings.

Listen to your heart, but ask it questions, too.

You can’t cut off the emotion from a decision.  It’s just not healthy.  Instead, I ask myself why I am making a particular decision.  I question the speed in which I need to make the decision, and I consider the feelings of everyone the decision impacts.  I want to make sure that I consider the emotional effect of the outcome without letting it persuade me in the decision making.

Go with your gut.

Ultimately, no one can make the best decision for your particular situation but  you.  If you’ve put thought and research into the decision, and  you’ve kept your emotions in check. Then, sometimes, you just need to take the leap.

Once you make a decision, follow through with it.  If it doesn’t work out like you planned, try again. Perseverance is an emotion that should be a part of every financial decision you make.

How do you balance your heart with your wallet?

 

Christina Brown is the creator of Northern Cheapskate, a blog dedicated to frugal living through coupons, freebies, and money-saving ideas.  She lives in the rural north woods of Minnesota where she clips coupons, pinches pennies, and chases her three boys (a 6-year-old and twin 4-year olds) as a stay-at-home mom.

 


  • Karissagreen

    WOW!! This happened to us also. My husband and I felt so badly. Our 2 young daughters love our dog and did not understand what was going on. Our vet recommended that we take our dog to a specialty hospital where the charge would be $300-$600 just to find out if they could help her:( We decided with the vets help that we could wait 1 more week and do eye drops and keep our dog out of the sun. I emailed other mommies in church who would understand the pain of a decision we were going to make that would affect our kids so deeply. We all prayed together-after all if Jesus knows the amount of hairs on our head and whether a bird falls-I believe he cares for a dog and the hearts of hurting children. After a week of prayer and rest and eye drops and no sun-OUR DOG was healed:) Thankyou Lord!! We had no idea that a dog could be so expensive, and count ourselves blessed here. I will pray for you guys!

    • http://www.northerncheapskate.com/ Christina@Northern Cheapskate

       I’m so happy the drops (and prayers!) worked for your dog!  Our little dog is doing much better and should make a full recovery in a few weeks. 

  • http://www.momdropbox.com Audrey

    Good points here.  We are dealing with this balance right now as we search for a preschool for our kids.  Yes, you want the ‘best’ for your kids, but it has to be tempered with reasonableness regarding schedule, price, location, etc.  Good luck with your dog- hope she gets better soon. 

    • http://www.northerncheapskate.com/ Christina@Northern Cheapskate

      Thanks for your kind words, Audrey.  She’s doing much better! 

      We’ve struggled with how many (and which) activities our children should participate in.  It’s hard to say “no” sometimes, but I also understand that it’s a part of life. You always have to look at the big picture!

  • http://aboutone.com/ Tara from AboutOne

    Great points. The same thing has happened to us several times; we have 4 cats. When are pets are beloved, the decision is so much harder, and there’s rarely one right answer.

    Other times that I’m tempted to spend for emotional reasons are dates with my husband or our friends, vacations, and holidays. It’s always tempting, isn’t it?

    • http://www.northerncheapskate.com/ Christina@Northern Cheapskate

      We recently faced a similar decision when we chose to go out to dinner with a friend we hadn’t seen in several years.  The emotions won out, and I’m grateful we got to spend time with a friend, but it put a strain on the budget.

  • Pingback: What the Cheapskate is Reading | Northern Cheapskate

  • TheStressedMom

    I have to be careful as I have one daughter who is having her first baby and another daughter who is getting married, both in the month of June! There are SO many things I want to do and buy for both of them, but I have to take a step back, and be more reasonable. 
    Many of the items for the baby we have found used, and saved a bunch of money there. The wedding is non-traditional with the biggest cost being the rental of the facility, which my husband and I are paying for.  So it feels like I am not “helping” her with the wedding. As time gets closer though, I am sure she will have plenty I can help with!Great post, and so glad your dog is better!BerniceFast, easy, healthy snacks

  • Pingback: Learning to Break the Cycle of Debt | Northern Cheapskate

Previous post:

Next post: